Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ella Wright's avatar

As I just commented in my other reply to you, your reflections on trauma, activism, and The Great Turning resonate deeply with my own research. But what struck me most in this piece is your focus on how we move through this moment—not just as individuals processing trauma, but as entire societies navigating collapse, transformation, and renewal.

You write about trauma not only as a wound but as a force that can shape us toward something new. This reminds me of the ways Indigenous and decolonial knowledge systems have long understood trauma—not as an individual affliction, but as a relational rupture that calls for collective repair. There is no healing in isolation. Trauma is always a story about disconnection—disconnection from land, from history, from ancestors, from our own bodies. And yet, the dominant Western approach to trauma often reduces it to something personal, something to "overcome" rather than something to metabolize into a different way of being.

What you’re describing—this shift from panic to purpose, from resistance to rhythm—is what I see as a trauma-informed politics of futurity. Not just the work of dismantling what is broken, but the work of listening for what wants to emerge. The three dimensions of activism you lay out are all necessary, but I think the real work now is in learning how to weave them together. The fight against immediate harm, the building of new structures, the shifting of consciousness—these are not separate tasks. They are interwoven rhythms of transformation.

What you wrote about fawning also struck me, because I see that pattern play out so often in activist spaces—the fear of rupture, the desire to "keep the peace" even when justice demands confrontation. But what if we reframe rupture itself as a form of connection? What if breaking open is not just destruction, but the first step toward repair?

You end with water, and I can’t stop thinking about that image—because if there’s one force on this planet that knows how to hold rupture and repair in the same motion, it’s water. Water dissolves. Water reshapes. Water finds a way through. And I think that’s what this moment is asking of us—not just to fight or flee, not just to freeze or fawn, but to flow. To be fluid enough to navigate uncertainty. To be strong enough to carve new paths. To be gentle enough to hold what needs holding.

So here’s to moving like water. With you in the current.

Ella

xx

Expand full comment
Stephen Bau's avatar

I have come across references to gender biases in research around stress responses:

“First, although the National Institutes of Health (NIH) now emphasizes the need to include women and female animals in clinical research, decades of research on the topics reviewed herein have been conducted using only men and male animals.”

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10978685/#Sec5

“But fight or flight is only part of a bigger picture, according to Shelley Taylor, Ph.D., a psychology professor at the University of California, Los Angeles, and her colleagues. In the Psychological Review, the researchers describe how stress can elicit another behavioral pattern they call ‘tend and befriend’—especially in females. Their new theories may have profound implications for understanding the differences between how men and women react to stress.”

https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/articles/200009/tend-and-befriend

This is the approach I am feeling, Ganga, when you speak of tending our relationship with the living world.

“It can be learning to be in right relationship—with land, with history, with each other. It is the work of unlearning and reimagining. It is slow work, often invisible, but without it, structural change cannot hold.”

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts